Fifteen seasons, 300 rounds, five opinions
The five underwriters disagree about how much the distant past tells you about next season. That cannot be settled by argument, only by capital. This runs real Nigerian rainfall from 2011-2025 through the same auction rules the contract enforces and reports who was still solvent at the end.
Where the capital went
| Agent | Won | Bid | Declined | Premiums | Claims | Loss ratio | Final capital | Profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| uw-1 Longrun Every season since 1981 counts equally; the climate is noise around a mean. | 241 | 267 | 33 | 3,033.49 | 4,930.00 | 163% | 103.49 | −1,896.51 |
| uw-2 Recent Only the last 15 seasons tell you anything; the old ones are a different climate. | 35 | 300 | 0 | 326.15 | 160.00 | 49% | 2,166.15 | 166.15 |
| uw-3 Blend Split the difference and charge a little more for not knowing which is right. | 2 | 300 | 0 | 43.25 | 130.00 | 301% | 1,913.25 | −86.75 |
| uw-4 Cautious Price the worse of the two views. Survive first, compete second. | 0 | 300 | 0 | 0.00 | 0.00 | n/a | 2,000.00 | 0.00 |
| uw-5 Capacity Blend the views, then ration the last of the capital by charging more for it. | 20 | 300 | 0 | 369.46 | 420.00 | 114% | 1,949.46 | −50.54 |
Loss ratio is claims paid over premiums earned. Above 100% means the agent paid out more than it was paid to take the risk. Every agent started with 2,000.00 USDC.
What actually happened
Longrun prices on all 45 seasons since 1981, so it quotes the lowest premium of the five, wins most of the market — and pays for it. Recent, which trusts only the last fifteen seasons, is the only agent that made money. Cautious wins nothing at all and ends with its capital intact, which is exactly what “survive first, compete second” buys you.
Nobody told these agents the climate is drying. The rainfall did, and the ones that would not listen lost their own capital. That is the whole mechanism: a market where mispricing is punished with the underwriter’s money rather than the farmer’s.
Capacity’s behaviour is emergent rather than scripted. Its load rises as its book fills, so it stops being the cheapest bid late in a season and Recent picks up the business it drops.
Every round
All 300 rounds with every bid, including the declines, are in sim/results/results.json. The most recent twenty are below.
| # | Season | Site | Strike | Payout | Winner | Cleared at | Rain | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 300 | 2025 | makurdi | 120.6 | 80.00 | no bid | — | 109.7 | — |
| 299 | 2025 | ibadan | 104.7 | 50.00 | recent | 7.06 | 129.4 | expired |
| 298 | 2025 | nsukka | 71.7 | 50.00 | blend | 19.66 | 40.9 | paid out |
| 297 | 2025 | enugu | 71.1 | 30.00 | capacity | 10.26 | 53.6 | paid out |
| 296 | 2025 | maiduguri | 62.2 | 80.00 | recent | 16.94 | 41.8 | paid out |
| 295 | 2025 | sokoto | 92.0 | 50.00 | recent | 7.06 | 257.9 | expired |
| 294 | 2025 | kano | 63.2 | 50.00 | capacity | 12.66 | 42.7 | paid out |
| 293 | 2025 | kaduna | 89.9 | 30.00 | longrun | 7.04 | 144.9 | expired |
| 292 | 2025 | makurdi | 120.6 | 80.00 | capacity | 31.86 | 109.7 | paid out |
| 291 | 2025 | ibadan | 97.7 | 50.00 | recent | 3.53 | 129.4 | expired |
| 290 | 2025 | nsukka | 60.5 | 50.00 | capacity | 14.21 | 40.9 | paid out |
| 289 | 2025 | enugu | 70.4 | 30.00 | longrun | 6.26 | 53.6 | paid out |
| 288 | 2025 | maiduguri | 60.0 | 80.00 | recent | 11.29 | 41.8 | paid out |
| 287 | 2025 | sokoto | 80.7 | 50.00 | recent | 7.06 | 257.9 | expired |
| 286 | 2025 | kano | 66.7 | 50.00 | longrun | 11.74 | 42.7 | paid out |
| 285 | 2025 | kaduna | 89.9 | 30.00 | longrun | 7.04 | 144.9 | expired |
| 284 | 2025 | makurdi | 118.4 | 80.00 | capacity | 27.38 | 109.7 | paid out |
| 283 | 2025 | ibadan | 104.7 | 50.00 | recent | 7.06 | 129.4 | expired |
| 282 | 2025 | nsukka | 60.5 | 50.00 | longrun | 10.43 | 40.9 | paid out |
| 281 | 2025 | enugu | 83.1 | 30.00 | longrun | 8.61 | 53.6 | paid out |